The aftermath of the First World War sees the upper class of Perthshire coming to terms with changes in their lifestyle. Among these is Dandy Gilver, struggling financially and unoccupied since her husband's return from the Front. When asked by a more solvent friend to investigate a diamond theft she is at first excited by the prospective adventure, especially when it is coupled with the offer of payment. However, soon a suspicious death apparently linked to the theft paints a more sinister picture.
Dandy is an engaging, likeable sleuth. Her approach is direct and her initial naiveté does put her at risk of being manipulated by others. She forms a lively partnership with the dead girl's fiancé, Alec Osborne, and they proceed with their investigation through intelligent discussion and banter. Little interference comes from Dandy's family, with her husband Hugh focused on estate improvements and their sons spending most of the time away at school. However, when necessary, Dandy offers some amusing excuses for absences to visit potential witnesses, such as going to look at a litter of puppies which are being given away.
Dandy tends to babble when questioning possible witnesses. Yet there is charm in her manner in her perseverence, her deciding she has nothing to lose of which she is aware. Descriptions of reactions to this unconventional approach are excellent, as is that of the quiet, philosophical manner in which she accepts clear doubts about her mental stability.
This is an excellent debut novel, conveying the atmosphere of the period and
the twists of the plot. Characters are well drawn and the plot is logical but
not obvious. There is a comfortable feel, with elements of humour. This can
put the reader at ease in a way which makes the darker aspects stand out all
the more.
------
Mary Andrea Clarke
This is the author’s first novel